Personally I think everyone who can should have a rooster. There are good things about them too, if you can find a well mannered one, and in my experience that shouldn't be too hard. I've had about 10 different roos and not a single one was mean. That said, I do believe some breeds are more easy going than others, and I devote a good portion of my day every day to watch them and care for them, so they are quite used to me. The breeds I have/had were Buff orpington, EE, Polish, and Brahma. Roosters can be loud and aggressive, but they are not all created equal. They make devoted protectors of the flock. They can call to their girls and tell them to hide when danger is near, and they will go out and face it themselves so the threat doesn't go after the hens. They lead their girls to good sources of food and some even show them where the nesting boxes are and hint as to what they are used for, so the girls get it quicker. If you spend enough time with them, they start to recognize you as the caregiver and the boss. Mine won't hardly even do any dominance displays when I'm out with them. They don't even crow after 8am. This morning, I was out with them and heard a commotion behind the above ground pool. I walked over to check it out and found my head rooster (a Light Brahma) gettin' frisky on one of the girls. The moment he saw me he jumped off and tried to act like it never happened lol! I'm not kidding, he was totally thinking 'Oh, uh, nothin' to see here, boss'. I really like him though, he is always the last to get in the coop because he counts everyone and patrols the perimeter once or twice to make sure it's safe before he gets in. Good ones are out there!! Maybe you have one!