The Great Guinnea Debate/Pros and cons.

Before you get guineas you must go see and especially HEAR some in person to determine if you & your neighbors could live with their noise. That to me is their biggest drawback. Their calls can be loud, frequent, and repetitive. My kids like to think they're saying "butt-CRAAK!!! butt-CRAAK!!" and sometimes they sound like a deranged marching band going around the yard.

I have gotten accustomed to their sound, and none of the neighbors complain. But my friend's husband said to her "I don't care if they s**t gold bricks, don't you ever get birds that sound like that!"

I like having them for comedic relief, they look like something drawn by Dr Seuss. They are very easy to care for since they free-range around the yard by themselves all day, and put themselves to roost at night. Before I clipped their wings they would fly over the fences and up on the roof, but now they stay in our 1.5 acre yard. They lay their delicious bullet-proof eggs in a communal nest.

I have 3 lavendar hens now since something recently got the 4th hen. These particular girls have docile temperments, not bothering the children or the other chickens. But I also had a lavendar guinea cock from this same batch (all 5 bought at the feed store) who attacked my then 5-year-old son, pecking him all around his eye, while he was just innocently playing in his sand box. Though we excused him by saying he'd been driven crazy by his 4 shrieking wives, we still dispatched him within the hour. The 4 hens never seemed to miss him.

I think temperment depends on the individual birds you get, some will be more aggressive than others.

I wish you the best with your decision!
 
Thanks for the thread Speck. I agree one bad apple will spoil the whole bunch. I've always had silkies but wanted Polish, so I raised 9. They seemed to be fine for awhile but started getting VERY aggressive towards my silkies so off they went to another home.
If I had problems with polish, then I already know what I'm in store for with guinea's.
Having Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever is not fun. DH is "pretty good" at keeping the grass cut here in NC, but we have woods surrounding us, so it's ticks, chiggers (red bugs), etc. I refuse to use pesticides on the property. (Only 3 acres).
 
Quote:
OMG...I hear hammering next door! I think they're building another coop for the THUGS!!
fl.gif
fl.gif
fl.gif
fl.gif
 
My neighbors can't say a danged thing about a few guineas...their cows get loose once in a while and leave little "gifts" in our yard
lol.png
(Doesn't bother me.) Plus several of our neighbors have guineas. Sound travels very funny where we live due to the lay of the land, so while we hear every crow of the roo half a mile away, the guy who owns the roo never hears us.

As for my two silkies (we had three but lost her to the dreadful heat last weekend) they rule our roost-our RIR's are already twice as big as the silkies, but the reds fear them! I think bantams are like the chihuahua of the chicken world-small bird, HUGE attitude.

To the person offering me some keets-I would love to take you up on it, but that dh will require a great deal of discussion over the logistics of a few more birds. I'll pm you when I convince him. Honestly, though, the cost of Frontline for three big dogs has to be higher than keeping a half dozen more birds.
 
Guineas are practically self sufficient in the summer monthgs. I have not put feed out for them in a month because they havnt touched what I put out a month ago. There are lots and lots of bugs & weed seeds on 7 acreas. I have noticed they chase the black birds and doves away from the bird feeders and pick up the feed that falls, which is not entirely a bad thing. I hate to have black birds knock all the feed out of the bird feeders and empty them in one afternoon.

I havnt bought frontline all season this year. I have only seen one or two ticks on the dogs.
 
Guineas are great!!
big_smile.png

We had 4 males and 2 females but something got all but 3 males.Yes they are loud but if anything moves in the night they will wake you.Ours roost right outside the bedroom window.They have never gotten on our cars and on our house only a handful of times
We have had a few ticks on our dogs but keep in mind we have 7 acres only 3 guineas.I have to buy frontline for the fleas. We kept them up in the coop with chickens for about 2 weeks.After that I let all out in the day.After we had a hen go broody they got banished and now just sleep in the yard.
I hatched off 3 new keets.Hope they are all females.
fl.gif


Debbiez:)
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom