Joey, the bird on the left has quality feathers on the saddle. The bird on the right has shredded feathering on the saddle.
This is very common. I would work on the feather quality of the birds before worrying too awful much about the taint of red in the tail feathers. There's a pecking order or triage of things. You cannot work on everything at once or there'd be no birds in the breeding pen.
Feather is super high on the list. Type and size is the highest on the list. Combs are further down, as is the taints of red in the tail.
Hope that helps.
Thank you for pointing that out... it helps
tremendously. I have noticed the shredded feathers on the saddles of some of the pullets, but wasn't sure if it was a grooming issue or something genetic. I was hoping it was the former of the two. I've always heard to work on type first, then feather quality, and
then worry about color. That's why I haven't been too awfully concerned when people comment about a pinch of red in their tails. I may never get rid of the red, but if nothing else, I'll do what I can to keep it at a minimum. It obviously tortures a lot of the pros, too.
I was watching my birds from about 40 yards this evening, and the one thing that really stood out was their stances. Several of my cockerels were displaying (near) perfect bricks, and although the pullets were't quite as rectangular, most of them looked "full"... if that makes any sense. They still have a good bit of growing to do, and I can see them changing ever-so-slightly on a daily basis.
I know you said that no amount of feed can fix pie shape, but it's rather strange that my cockerels were very broad before I moved them out of the cool (72F) basement into the scorching heat ... and simultaneously changed their feed. I've seen pics of their parents, and they have very broad backs. Is it possible that the change in environment, temperature, feed,
tremendous growth spurt,
and molting at the very same time would have played a role in the cockerels slimming down like they did? Oh... and I still haven't wormed them. Oops. It's not just the reds, either. All of my other and older birds lost weight this summer. It's been rather brutal down here. I truly want to believe that they will broaden back when they start putting on some weight.