Well if you look at the polish up close the feathers are rounded. The lacing make it look rooish, but Its crest is uniform and the feathers are round. No pointy or hackle feathers either. It looks more like my Polish pullets than roo, but is the only bearded I have. I have posted pictures of it in the Polish thread. I went down and gave the sultan another look and it does look more round than the pics, but it is so windy its hard to tell. I will keep a eye on it. It was a freeby and there are 10 bantam in the pullets in that coop and only one LF roo who is in there letting its broken toe heal so if it is a roo it will be fine.