Yes, you could, and I have tried it and didn't like it. They're not cost effective IMO, but mostly because it's so much more work to weight them down so the wind doesn't blow them away. With the sheet plastic I can roll it out, weight down the sides and corners, then slice an X or 3" cut down the row however far apart I want them. I'll do 5-10 cuts, poke the seed in and move down to the next section. It's very fast. This year the only Bantam that came up good was in the plastic, which I had pre installed and ready to go. DH had rototilled the Hopi bed so the plastic had been removed.

And In the deer fenced (ha!) garden, where the Golden Bantam is, I had pine needles handy to give a thin mulch over the cuts, so I used it. If I'd had time I would have put some on the Blue Hopi too. (Which is 300 yards away from the deer fenced area, but the deer didn't bother it last year. Neither did the raccoons) Also, on the plastic there's the sturdiness factor, which is why I prefer 6 mil. I want to be able to walk on it without it tearing. This system was actually first recommended to me years ago by a old friend who's a retired fish and game biologist and farmer. He had secured some rare(?) Oaxaca Indian Mexican corn seed for me and wanted to make sure I didn't waste it!

that corn grew 15' tall!!! Being a rather hardheaded sort, tho, I tried to do the next years crop WITHOUT using the plastic. Nada. Did I learn? Nope. Not right away....until I got the blue Hopi and I remembered...
