The thing is, while well intentioned, I almost cringe everytime I hear about someone splinting a splay-leg or 'assisting' a hatched egg... or any number of other interventions. It is a dis-service to the breed to allow things to survive that otherwise would not! This is how we ended up with non-broody hens, chickens that struggle to live past 12 weeks, and roosters that are unable to fend for themselves and protect their flock.
On a side note, while not everyone can have roosters, I will say that it's benefits are awesome. I honestly don't know if I can replace my current alpha roo. He is ambivalent to children, cautious of strangers and ever vigilant in protecting the flock. I have witnessed the regular warning calls, and have even seen him fight off hawks several times this Winter.
I'm no expert/super experienced breeder, but if you don't breed a splay legged chick or a help-out, why wouldn't you help them? Granted, if they were in the wild they would die, but as long as care is taken to not hatch eggs from them, I see no reason not to.
If any of you guys have a good reason why not too, please say so. I'm still learning![]()
You just said what I was about to say...
It's been my experience that the majority of eggs that need assistance, and chicks that need tending to legs and/or toes, are chicks that have been artificially incubated, not those incubated under hens.
Really good input, and I would like to add my personal experience and thought on this as my perspective has changed over the years.
Why would you not want to assist/treat a struggling chick or bird especially if it is a pet?
Unfortunately the weak chick usually grows up to be a weaker bird in the flock who often becomes the vector of illness since their immune system is usually lower because of either poor genetics or poor development. This plays out in many ways from being the first to catch and share illness to parasites.
Therefore, I have learned to take a harder nosed approach to struggling chicks and birds. My situation is different in that I broody hatch, and I breed for flock sustainability and egg production, but I know what people speak of...I also have a "tender heart" and enough medical savvy to intervene....but then learned to regret it.
Here is an example of why I have learned to regret intervention. I once messed up a hatch of coveted shipped eggs (which probably had messed up air cells though I checked) trying to assist a spindly failure to thrive chick (fell away from nest and was unable to get up on its own back to mom so I replaced and kept replacing) and then messed momma up on the nest with a sibling chick pipping....my intervention in trying to get the failure chick (probably genetically weak) to stick with momma caused a shrink wrapped situation with the pipping chick...which of course led me to intervene again...which of course led to omphalitis due to its extended hatch time before I figured it out..which of course led to artificial brooding and antibiotics for those chicks...and then smaller chicks to the naturally hatched siblings...which was likely symptoms of latent bacterial infection or abdominal weakness...thus lowered immunity. These chicks never did as well and became the "mite magnets" for the flock as hens that year no matter how much I treated.
I played that scenario out with numerous coveted hatches until I realized I was not doing any favors to my saved birds or my flock. Now that I hatch my own eggs from my own flock, I absolutely will not assist nor keep an animal that is not productive and thriving in my environment (assuming good husbandry.... food/water/cleanliness) as I do not want to propagate those weaker genes and have a constantly spiraling downward flock.
Even self inflicted poor hatching experiences can set a bird up to lifelong weaker immunity as bacterial infection can weaken the whole intestinal fortress through that initial contact with the environment (yolk sac/abdominal cavity).
I'm about to cull a coveted bird (one of the last adults purchased) because of her breed but she's developed a tumor which is something I don't want to breed forward. Kills me to have to do this as I really wanted her egg color, her feather color genetics, and she is a sweet bird, but that type of genetics is not something I want to forward and her weakening condition (she gets around fine, but the tumor is growing to an alarming size) will eventually cause her to succumb to some disease/parasite which she will inflict on the rest of the flock as she becomes the petri dish.
My thoughts.
LofMc
Last edited: