I don't know. How big a batch is it? My recommendation would be to start over with a very small batch: about a quart, and once you get that going, you could use it for starter to do what ever size you need. I do 2 containers which each hold 2 quarts of pellets and enough liquid to make the right consistency. Feed out one container per day, and there is always an other container ready for the next day. Mine smells a bit yeasty. Puffs up like rising bread dough. For a quart, a tablespoon of ACV with the mother would be plenty.