Not sure since it is not sure what color egg the rooster hatched from if the other 2 lay light brown or tan eggs you would most likely get brown egg layers unless he carries the blue egg gene then you could get brown/ blue or green. I would try it and see but that is me I love mutt chickens. I have one that lays pretty pink eggs. I do have 3 bantam EE's that lay blue eggs my rooster came from a brown egg so I am going to hatch their eggs to try and get some green egg layers. Good luck.
Here is a picture of my Ameraucana hen she has a pea comb.
Here is a picture of my EE bantam
Here is a picture of my Ameraucana hen she has a pea comb.

Here is a picture of my EE bantam

Last edited: