I have used both straw and shavings, in my opinion....straw doesn't keep the temp any warmer in the coop and it doesn't do a good job with the odor or absorbing moisture. This year I will NOT use straw or the deep litter method. I also have had 2 impacted crops after I introduced straw to my young ones when I put out a nest box for them to practice in, they tore all the straw out of it and ate every bit. My older chickens seemed to know it was not entirely edible and they did fine but I doubt my young ones learned their lesson.
the deep litter method was a royal pain to clean when spring hit and when the weather got passed the freezing point it smelled bad, now I did not use the DE...that may have helped. Shavings for me for ever! I have a few bales of straw remaining and I will use those for wind block and around the outside of the coop for insulation.
the deep litter method was a royal pain to clean when spring hit and when the weather got passed the freezing point it smelled bad, now I did not use the DE...that may have helped. Shavings for me for ever! I have a few bales of straw remaining and I will use those for wind block and around the outside of the coop for insulation.