The pullet in the center is the one in question. I purchased her as a Black Australorp, but upon getting her home and taking a closer look realized there is no way she's a BA. Her eyes are orange, has a rose comb, black legs and copper colored feathering right around her head. Her body shape is very similar to my BCM. She recently laid her first egg, it was a large, dark brown egg...similar in shape and color to my BCM.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.