It all gets easier with time. You figure out, adjust, do better.I know how you feel about all the advice. But really the fact is, not one thing is going to work for every roo out there. They are like kids, all with different personalities and different things that work with them. All 6 of my kids are punished differently for their behavior or actions. Grounding only works on a couple, the corner works for a couple, and sometimes it just takes some one on one talking. Whatever you choose to do will either work or it won’t, but at least your trying.
I too think that space is good for any chicken, especially the roos but the fact is it doesn’t always work that way. I too have problems with hawks, owls, coyotes, raccoons, and opossums. So the reality of them free ranging, yes possible, but is not ideal. Especially because of how open our property is for the sky but also how flat everything is. And yes coyotes do run during the day here too, so if one seen a chicken it wouldn’t take much for it to take off with it. There is a neighbor of ours, whose daughter is friends with ours, had Brahmas and Rhode Island reds. Well we seen on RIR that was hit on the road and then we noticed less and less chickens roaming in their yard. Well we stopped by to talk to them and they were picked off by the predators around here. But this is their first year having them and they didn’t even have a secure coop for them at night. Now they are down to like 2 chickens. At least last I noticed. I don’t think they care about their birds like we do though either. To hear them talk it is more “they are just animals” feel to the conversation. But anyway the point really is, is that predictors act fast when they know a free meal isn’t far.
We are just trying to help because we like you and have been there done that. Some of the worst advice I followed was holding a rooster down and walking through and showing dominance


When I treat them as a prey animal it all makes sense and I get the results that help me to relax and enjoy my flock. It is not all about the eggs for me.