Hatchery: Sand Hill Preservation Center
Date chicks received: Spring 2005 and May 2007
What you ordered: Rhode Island Red, Light Brown Leghorn, and Exchequer Leghorn
Positive Feedback: The Rhode Island Reds turned out to be pretty decent in '05.
I do have some good looking RIRs again in 2007, but most of the roosters' combs were not to my satisfaction. It seems like that was the case in '05 also.
Negative Feedback: In 2005, the Brown Leghorn cock I saved for breeding turned out to not be aggressive enough and the pullets grew spurs their first year. One of the Exchequers was mixed with Dorking blood and a cock I saved was black without white mottling.
In 2007, the Leghorns had decreased in quality to a noticeable extent. A few Brown Leghorns with pink flesh instead of yellow for legs and other faults (side sprig and wrong wing feather markings) and Exchequers of a poor type with roosters' combs dented on one side. One Exchequer actually was a cross beaked chick in the box, and I have never seen one. Also had never seen a side sprig. Have only seen pictures in books of such defects before.
Other info: I posted this because I want to warn people that I do not think the hatchery does an acceptable job of breed preservation. They are a not for profit corporation with preservation as their expressed goal. But they do not put together good breeding pens, and you get birds that lack the accepted appearance for the breed. I have spent a large sum of money and time on preserving these three breeds and wanted to point out that most hatcheries care about producing numbers, which equals money. Quality is not the priority.
Will you order from them again? Maybe, just for RIRs or Buckeyes. I will not order Leghorns, unless I talk to the owners about what the parent chickens will be. Otherwise I would be foolish to pay good money for the birds, plus all the food they will eat, only to have Leghorns to butcher in the fall.