I dont know on the black one. Its hackle feathers looks like roo but the comb and really lack of wattles looks like pullet. What kind of comb does it have looks straight to me but maybe I'm not seeing it right. All my straight combed roos combs and wattles were much larger then that at 12 to 14 weeks. To make you feel better my DD's D'Anvers are pullets but none egg squats and crows. Hows that for confused.