Close, but not quite.......the cherry egger "is" a cross of the Rhodies and some of it's close relatives and they have to be bred from cock to hen in the proper direction or you will get something entirely different. Other wise why would most hatcheries, list all three birds separately and sometimes have one breed but not the other? I breed my own specifics such as the "Eggers," New Hampshires and Production Reds and believe me after an expensive mistake or two I found just because a sales person claims they know what they are talking about it doesn't necessarily make it true. I've found in the past when the end of the hatching season nears any "Red" chicken can become New Hampshire, Production Red, Rhode Island or Cherry Egger. They also miss label eggs on occasion........all hatcheries make mistakes. A couple of years ago I purchased 100 Cherry Egger pullets........received 97 pullets 3 of the best looking Rhodies I had ever seen........So yes they are a very similar bird, so like any poultry that is line bred, Xed and bred back you will get some that are very similar to the original parent stock. BTW, at 1 year of age I sold two of those Rhodies @$100 each. That's how good they looked........the other has a well deserved position with a dozen select breeding hens. Remember "ALL" MODERN CHICKENS are a cross by nature or intentionally. Very little stock from any of the original breeds are still around.