I have raised Bourbon Reds for 3 years now and just love them. Very friendly and gentle. Mine haven't done too well at going broody, but they lay well and the eggs are fertile.
Last spring I had Spanish Black Tom that I crossed with a BR hen and this is one of the chicks I got. The best looking of the bunch I think. And I was surprised at the resemblance between it and the Narrangaset. Next spring I intend to breed it again, either with a black/slate mix or a BR/slate mix hen. I also have some BR/blue slate mix that I call a chocolate slate. The blue slate with a definate chocolate tinge to it.
And they all taste good!!
So I think the choice really does come down to preference of colors. I have some BR I'll segregate as pure breeders and then some others I plan to play with and see what I get. They will be mostly eaters any way and once the feathers come off most of us couldn't tell the difference.
Once agqain you come to the rescue. Thank you very much. I was asking because I have the opportunity to pick up a big Nag tom in kaufman TX and I am getting my boubon reds this weekend. I was wanting to decide if I wanted to go get the Tom. i think i will after seeing your birds Cc and CoalbyNTX.