The first rooster we had to cull my husband took his head off but I didn't like the flapping and the mess so this time I decided to try the broomstick method. I am not very big and strong but figured I would give it my best shot. I felt a 'pop' in the neck but then I started to worry because the roo still flapped a bit and twitched his legs, and looked like it was still breathing for what seemed like an age. It seems I did do it right because he stopped flapping and went all floppy but my worry is have I just hurt him and not killed him? At least when you chop the head off you know you have done the deed. Think I might go back to the chop method for future.