cackle hands down! never had a dead peep in the box, never had sick or deformed birds, very good quality of birds. and they have awsome specials and deals. and they have a wonderful selection and the best prices around. customer service is great, they are very friendly, very helpful. there birds actually look like the birds in the catalog for the most part, and the majority of the photos in the catalog and on the website are of their OWN birds. you wont get that from mcmurry.i really like cackle and will continue to order from them.
to contrast.........at mcmurry they just have drawings of birds and their inferior and intensely inbred and poor stock look NOTHING LIKE the birds in the drawings. there shipping practices are questionable, and they routinely forget parts of your order. but thats just my opinion.