Quote:
If you are asking this question, then the correct answer is "whatever breed the EXPERIENCED, preferably PROFESSIONAL HORSEMAN who is guiding your search
tells you that you should look for"
Really really.
Also, try to be taking lessons somewhere that has a good variety of horses in their lesson stable, so that you can see what types of horses you do (and don't) get along well with. For instance some people love the draft-horse temperament, other people loathe it. (Not actually too awful many people in between, in fact!) Similar with other breeds and personality types and movement types. The more you know about what you actually deal well with, butt-in-saddle, the likelier you'll wind up with a suitable horse.
Good luck, have fun,
Pat
I have to disagree with that...ther are waaaay too many "experienced, professional horsemen" out there who are going to direct you right into whatever they have for sale, not necessarily what you need. There's one on practically any given horsey corner around here.
I'd ride at several places, try out several horses in lessons with legit trainers and try to find something you like that fits well with where you are in riding, what you want to do and your comfort level. Ride it a lot in several different situations, not just the same one over and over. Then try to buy or maybe even lease first. If you find something you absolutely can't live without, keep that to yourself and try to bargain wisely. Don't let people know you are looking to buy, but that you are looking to learn. If they know you want to buy right off the bat they are more likely to try steering you into a sale, IMO.
I wouldn't buy either of those horses pictured either, unless you have quite a bit of personal experience with either and like them. I wouldn't necessarily let a swayback scare me off if the horse has other very good features, like if I sensed a good reliable lifetime kind of horse in one ...this swayback is an defect caused by ligaments in the back but I have known horses with swaybacks who could actually carry weight quite comfortably for long periods of time. Some breeds are prone to it as are some bloodlines. Not something I would get if I could help it though. There is way too much out there available right now in horses so it's a buyer's market.