Which is the better silkie rooster to use

[Taylettice]

I am picking up these silkie girls this week, I am aware that they arent the best quality and I'm not too sure what their color would be classified as. I am wondering with rooster would give me the better pairing in your opinions. My black and silver rooster is a very nice quality, my white silkie is a frizzled silkie. My white silkie has the off colored comb I'm aware but he came from a hen and rooster pairing that were both pure black. I'm wondering who would be best paired to these two hens

 

[The Moonshiner]

I'd go with the black and silver one since its an actual silkie.
Your white "silkie" that is frizzled with the red comb is a silkie mix so it depends if you want to produce silkie or silkie mix chicks.

 

[BlueBaby]

I agree with what Moonshiner said.