WHICH ROOSTER WOULD YOU CHOOSE? PLEASE VOTE

[rodriguezpoultry]

Go by their temperament and the treatment of them with the girls...

Neither is a good specimen for show but would make good pets.

 

[eggsited chickens]

"A" looks nice...pretty

 

[Sunny the Hippie Chick]

I read your other post about your rooster.. You said that the comb on your roo (1st pic) was damaged.. I would figure since it was damaged it wouldnt pass on genetically to the babies..

I would pick your current roo..

 

[cgmccary]

Pringle: I think youshould just watch them for a while and see which one is nice to the hens and you.They both look nice but ide decide on temperment and how nice they are.

I agree with Pringle. Sometimes the "nice temperament" quality doesn't come out until much later.​

 

[vortec]

A

He is absolutely stunning! He is broad and full. How old is he and do you have any idea of his weight?

vortec

 

[SproutGirl]

Let the hens choose. Who do they seem to like the best?

 

[vtsarahb]

which one is better with the ladies? From looks alone, I would choose rooster A.

 

[R@ndy]

I would choose A

 

[nzpouter]

I'll go and find a better roo... if you're only breeding for the table A, if you're planning to show, you need to get better.

 

[Majestic Lane Poultry]

Like most of us, it is about improving quality generation after generation. I do NOT like rooster A. The first thing I noticed is that there is no U shape in A but you can at least see the U in rooster B. Neither are show quality but for the next generation...and A&B are your only choices...B gets my vote.