Nice slow cooker, NEIGHBOR...I am in Smithtown! I use my Crock Pot (newest model) all the time! It lets me cook stuff whenever I want with no extra thought. I don't put my veggies in right away most of the time to avoid them being overcooked, BUT I DO like overcooked potatoes and carrots.
We used our toaster oven EVERY SINGLE DAY until we bought a Maytag Gemini stove which has two ovens..the top open being a smaller size to replace our toaster oven. Now we use it even more often.
I used my steamer quite often until I bought those steaming bags. Now I can steam veggies in the microwave. We just bought a new microwave with the ability to sense how long to cook and it is VERY cool! Now the steamer is only used for rice, but it's kind of like you said...in the pantry, so it's "out of sight, out of mind." I bought all kinds of things we rarely use, too.
We actually love a Belgian waffle maker...but we had problems finding a reasonably priced one that didn't have issues. So, we have bitten the bullet and order the $200 Kitchen Aid. Argh. We have waffles one night a week, usually. The Kitchen Aid makes two at a time, perfect for my husband and myself.
So, it seems like you are doing very well. The most used small appliance in our kitchen is the small flat screen TV by the kitchen table. LOL