Who dunnit?

[Tiffrz-N-Kidz]

Our first egg!!! And one the very next day from either the same one or a new layer.

The evidence:

The suspects:

 

[Dixiedoodle]

it looks like one of my RIRs first eggs..

 

[flgardengirl]

I'm guessing girl #2.

 

[Wendy'sChicksRock]

RIR is my guess...my eggs look just like that.....CONGRATS..

 

[dandelionheart]

But #1 looks RED. Any day if it isn't her to begin with.

 

[Yay Chicks!]

Pretty sure it was NOT #3

 

[sgtmom52]

Yay Chicks! :

Pretty sure it was NOT #3

I agree ~ I don't think "He" laid an egg!

My mistake ~ I was not familiar with the body style and tail of a silver phoenix hen.​

 

[Tiffrz-N-Kidz]

I was thinking 1 or 2. They both redded up last week.

I was told 3 is a Phoenix hen.

S/He is not crowing.

 

[swimmer]

My money goes on #2.

 

[Yay Chicks!]

I was told 3 is a Phoenix hen. S/He is not crowing.

Ah, well there ya go. I know nothing about Phoenix's. That'll teach me to jump to conclusions