If you grab them at night I think they will be more traumatized. Chickens have poor eyesight in dusk/dark and they might think you are a predator. I agree that you should TRY to get them today with mealworms as a lure if you can. Also, a friend, and each of you holding the sticks and trying to nudge them to your house if you can...Good luck! Can't wait to hear what happens!Hmmm... yeah, those were the two I was deciding between, grabbing them at night, or herding them into a cage or something.