Bigger is Better: Advice from one chicken keeper to another

By Mountain Peeps · Oct 12, 2017 · ·
  1. Mountain Peeps
    Bigger is Better: Advice from one chicken keeper to another

    I’ve been raising chickens for close to six years now. Compared to some, that’s a long time, and compared to others, that’s nothing. But, nevertheless, I have learned countless lessons throughout my years of chicken keeping. Lessons regarding things I should not have done, lessons regarding things I should have done differently, and lessons regarding things I should have done again or done better. It is because of one of these distinct lessons that I’m writing this article to share with you. A lesson I’m glad I learned and shall do my best to never repeat again. The lesson that: it is never smart to get just two chickens.

    Now, obviously, I need to give some explanation on my stance on this. Of course you’ve probably heard about the guideline that it’s not good to buy and raise one chicken by itself. Chickens are social creatures. Even if you intend to raise a chicken as a pet, it still is best if the bird has a friend or two of its own kind. When I first started raising chickens, I ordered five 5-day-old chicks from my local farm store. But, the employees messed up the order and, in order to receive the breeds I wanted, I had to buy one chick one day and the other four a few days later. Believe me when I tell you that those couple days with just the one chick were not pretty. As long as there was daylight, all you heard was crying from this poor chick. Even though I carried her with me in my pocket and spent every free moment with her, she still desperately craved the company of her own kind. As soon as I brought the other four chicks home, she was as content as can be. However, because there was an uneven number of chicks and none other of her same breed, she was still “alone”, so to speak. And to this day, she is still my loner hen. But she has the company of the other flock members, which is what she wanted and lacked in the first place.

    Three years ago, I decided to add to my flock. But because of limited space, I could only get two or three more birds. And that’s when I made the mistake of getting TWO. As you can imagine, with no other birds to be with, two chickens have no choice but to bond with one another. Despite the fact that I trained the two of them to be friendly and comfortable around people, I could not help the fact that they grew to be such close buddies. When I added them to the old flock, they were both put on the bottom of the pecking order next to each other. Now, after three years, the pecking order has changed a lot and the two are not the best of friends anymore. But, they have bonded with other flock members and still prefer each other over me.
    When I raised the five chicks, two of them really bonded with each other. Then, there was the loner. While the other two were the same breed and are still best buddies to this day, one of them, Gracie, really bonded with me. When I would sit with them, the others would peck at the grass around me, but Gracie would sit on my lap and preen my hair. She preferred the company of me to the company of her flock mates. And to this day, she still prefers sitting in my lap then scampering around the yard.

    Now, before I go on, I’d like to make a disclaimer: All of this happened with me wanting tame birds. I took the time to create bonds with each of my hens and get them used to me. They are all very friendly now. They can be picked up and held. But, only Gracie BEGS for it. Some people might not want to have a friendly flock, and if that’s the case, then this article will not be helpful for you. I’m writing to advise those looking to have a tame flock but also are contemplating getting just two birds. Also, this is just my experience. If you raised two chickens and had a different outcome, then that is great too!
    So, with all my backstory and disclaimer aside, here are the four main things I learned about raising two chickens at a time:

    1.) Your chances of having one particularly tame bird are highly reduced
    When you make the decision to buy two chickens, you essentially are giving up the fantasy of having a lap-loving pet. While, as previously stated, you do need to give your chickens their own kind for companionship, if you buy more than two, your chances of having one or more birds that really bond with you, go up. But, with just two birds, you, as the caretaker, are placed on the backburner. Remember that you can still successfully tame your birds, even if there are two of them. They just won’t see you as their priority to bond with.

    2.) Odd numbers are your best friend
    As I quickly discovered with my two chickens versus my five, odd numbers usually result in tamer birds. Using Gracie as an example again, she had the company of other birds but also didn’t have tunnel vision for only bonding with one other bird. She bonded with me over her feathered friends because she had the choice. Your chances of having a bird like this are increased with higher numbers of chickens. Also, it shouldn’t be a huge problem if you purchase a large even amount of chickens. Just as long as the birds have the option to bond with you over their significant other, if you will, your intentions of having tame chickens shouldn’t be harmed.

    3.) Things aren’t going to change as they age
    As was the case with my two chickens, when the pecking order changed and, they grew apart, they didn’t make me their new best friend. Rather, they just turned their attention to another flock member. Once the idea of bonding with another bird and not with you is engrained in a chicken’s brain, your hopes of having a singular tame bird, will pretty much be gone for good. Old habits die hard.

    4.) It’s not hopeless

    With all of this being said, I do not mean to discourage you. It is still 100% possible to achieve a tame flock, even if that includes them being friendlier towards each other than they are towards you. Don’t get me wrong: my flock is plenty tame. All of the chickens allow me to hold them, cuddle them, pet them, etc. They follow me around the yard and beg for treats. But, none of them compare to the bond Gracie and I share. I can honestly say that I think Gracie would make a better house pet than she would anything else. But, even she still craves the company of her flock members. She wants to be doing what they are doing, eating what they are eating, and investigating what they are investigating.

    Therefore, all this goes to say that if you purchase friendly breeds and put work into taming them, you will still, most likely, have a very docile flock. But, I also wanted to share this lesson with you so that you can avoid this potential problem if you have the same desires for a friendly flock as I did.
    Overall, chickens bond with their own kind before they do with people. This is their natural instinct and no one can change that. With that being said however, chickens are curious, domestic creatures that don’t take a ton of work to tame. And, one of the best things that can make the taming process easier, is by not raising just two chickens and by keeping the odd numbers in mind. Good luck on your chicken raising adventures!

    Below are some links further explaining how to actually tame chickens. Thanks for reading!


    Share This Article

    You, TheGirlOverThere, Sinful chick and 30 others like this.

Recent User Reviews

  1. ronott1
    "Good Article"
    4/5, 4 out of 5, reviewed Sep 10, 2018
    I like to have at least three because with only Two, it is very lonely for the survivor.

    Well written article
  2. N F C
    4/5, 4 out of 5, reviewed Aug 4, 2018
    Good food for thought (and something I had not given a great deal of thought to).
  3. Hope Hughes
    "Nice article set up"
    2/5, 2 out of 5, reviewed Jul 25, 2018
    You wote the article out great. But i do not 100% agree with the alot of it. I have raised 2 chicks and both have been extreamly social with me and the flock. And i have had some that were not. It believe it really just depends on the bird are how they feel. They are all different with different personalities.


To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. Sparrowsong98
    I recently got 3 polish and two marans, but the marans were 2 week olds and the polish were day olds, so we brooded them seperately. I had to pick both up to cuddle because the bond between them was very close and they could not stand not seeing each other. It was very cute to see them so close, and had no bad side for someone who does not tame their chickens. It even helped on several occasions where one had slipped out a hole in the run and was roaming wild. The other chick was frantic, and so I realized something was wrong much sooner and found the pullet before night. They still are best friends, but have added to their group (my flock is clickish for some reason so there are smaller flocks within my flock).
  2. Sinful chick
    I have one rooster that suffered a raccoon attack. I now have him inside with me spoon feeding him and carrying him with me everywhere. In the evening, I'll take him out to visit the 3others. (in a cage). I, personally, wonder if this hurts his feelings...(chickens are people, too). Should I subject him to this or not? He was the king, but now the other rooster took his place with My 2 hens. I feel bad for him. Am I totally nuts?
  3. TeenageRooster's Dad
    Great article! learned the hard way about taming the rooster "effect". This year I figured getting massive hens and a bantam roosie would even things out... so got 6 light Brahmas, 4 rhodes and a dutch bantam rooster... basically a 3.78lb, hourglass shaped, non-threatening, puffed up cock. ;)...

    turns out, even if parts "don't aligned" doesn't stop him from being a Stricklandesque 'yard monitor' looking for a Mcfly hen (back to the Future reference :) )
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  4. Toothpick
    I had tame chickens until I put a rooster in with them. I raised 6 chicks up to hens and I could pet them and pick them up and everything. I got a rooster from the neighbor that wasn't tame. Put it in with the chicks and slowly the hens turned on me. Now they all run from me.
  5. haileyeverhart
    I don't agree at all. I've gotten my chicks in pairs every year and have no problems. My hens are nice to me and just depends on the chicken whether they want to sit on your lap or not. Eventually as you add the pairs to the existing flock, they all get along and become friends. Plus they're not all the same age so my hens won't be dying at the same time.
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  6. Lauren Adams
    Great article! Five stars for sure I would just like to say I noticed in one of your pictures there was newspaper instead of wood shavings in one of your brooders. I recommend using wood shavings because newspaper is too slippery for chicks and can cause leg problems. Otherwise great article!
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  7. Ms Biddy
    Very nicely said! I never thought about it from that perspective but it makes sense.
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  8. JINTZ
    I love this article! :)
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  9. Fox2112
    Love it! :thumbsup
    Thanks for the advice!
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  10. ChickNanny13
    I agree with you, I'm limited to 4 - 6 pullets in my residential area & have learned what you're saying. I once had 3BLRW & 1EE, they got along but the EE was always odd man out. I've had 2RIR & 2BLRW, they got along but hung out with their own breed more. I've had 3BO, they got along but one seemed to be "left out" alot. They were all friendly & tame, came a running when I came out of the house but have learned it's best to have an even number of chiccks & at least 2 of a kind.

    I first started of with a chick that was given to me due to being pecked so bad by it's siblings, he was almost bald. He was my first, he was fine but spoiled, got along great with my indoor dog but when it was discovered he was a he & not a she, I had to rehome him. Turned out great, he became a house chicken.

    Another time I was given a single hatch; used a mirror, feather duster & stuffed animal. He's the one pictured in my Avatar. He worked out great but had to be rehomed cause he wasn't a she.

    So yes, I understand and agree with your article. I now have 4BOs but will be getting 2LO in June, this will be my first attempt in integration. Wish me luck :fl
      Mountain Peeps and Fox2112 like this.
  11. The Phantom
  12. Little Fuzzy
    Exactly what he said.
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  13. Sipplchicks
    Nice article and the photographs are great too!
      Mountain Peeps and Fox2112 like this.
  14. RodNTN
    Wonderful article, sis! I can say the same about my Buff Orpington pullet, Pumpkin. She does indeed prefer my company to her flock buddies. Again, great article!
      Mountain Peeps likes this.
  15. N F C
    Interesting article Sarah, you make some good points :thumbsup
      Mountain Peeps likes this.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: