I'm also really really bad at compromise, so all projects go just like this one... Over built, over planned, over budget, over effort, etc. Nice, but just to much of EVERYTHING.
Okay, well at the risk of boring all the regular members on here who have heard me say this a thousand times, I believe building bigger and stronger than you think you can possibly ever need or use will make your life so much easier in the long run.
My mistake: Building a coop, hutch style, big enough for 8 hens, thinking I would only have 6, so a Cadillac of a coop! So, I thought. I now have 4 coops, hutch style, not one that will hold all my 12 chickens. But, that's okay, because here's what I did right.
What I did right was build a huge run. Over the 4 years I've had my chickens, I have had reason to separate and divide, due to isolation and integration needs. Having so much room to work with merely meant putting in an internal fence for divisions. Having 4 coops has made separation/integration very easy for me. Right now, with 2 cockerels, I have 4 runs and coops being used to keep them separate from the hens/pullets and from each other. So, I'm glad I have the set up I do. But, it has meant that every year I have added something.
NOW, in March, we are building an 8x10 walk in coop with a fully enclosed and roofed run, minimally 10x12, that will be absolutely predator proof. They will still free range in the larger pens, but will have a safe haven to return to. So, year #5 begins coop #5.
Build as big and as solid as you can the first time around. You no longer need to ask me how I know.
