**UPDATE: Seller admitted being new (not new to chickens or breeding, but new to breeding Ameraucanas) and having not "done this for very long". She stated that "some call them Silver, some call them Blue". I let her know that there are both Blue and Silver (and even Lavender) Ameraucanas and that they are different. Fancy ME, of all people, giving her a lesson in Ameraucana colors!! lol But I did and I believe I did a really good job despite my own limited knowledge (I am a researchaholic and self proclaimed infomaniac, afterall). She states that she did purchase them as pure Ameraucanas from a farm who breeds/raises them, so they are not RK or TSC chickens. She offered the farm's info and more pictures of her flock. I let her know that the ones pictured are BBS and White, and Lavender and provided her a great Ameraucana recognized colors chart and more info on the breed. She thanked me.
Do I think she should be selling *Pure* Ameraucana's to the general public without proper knowledge of the breed that she can pass along to her customers who prioritize purity? No. Do I believe she has true Ameraucanas? Based on the pictures, Yes. Do I believe that's what I'll be getting? Provided she keeps her flocks separate (she also has cochins, Black Copper Marans, and some others), Yes. Do I believe she is dishonest? Not neccessarily; I simply think she isn't volunteering the whole truth (brand-new and has no clue what she's talking about). I mean, just say that.
Anyway, as I stated to someone in this thread, I am not looking to breed/raise/or sell stellar, show quality Ameraucanas (at least not anytime in the foreseeable future), but I DO want to let people know that the egg layers they get will absolutely produce blue eggs as they come from Pure blue egg layers AND I want to be able to produce green laying Easter eggers by crossing said pure Ameraucanas (recognized colors or not) with my Black Australorps. Simply put, I want people to get exactly what I tell them they are going to get when they come to get eggs from me. So, fingers crossed.