I take lots of photos of my chickens too.![]()
Muffs and beard look good, eye color looks correct, feather quality looks good. I can't tell much about either hens type from the photos. Taking photos from
the side is helpful when assessing type. Looks like she has a little ticking in her hackles (the specks in her neckline). I see ticking in wheatens occasionally but not very often in blue wheatens. It is always a balancing act, trying to get good color in the wing tips/tails without too much color. Lol! IMO, overall I think she is a pretty gal.
The only thing I really don't care for is her tail. It is fan-shaped, which is not correct for an Ameraucana. Looks like she could have some other breed in her genetic background. That is why I asked if she was a bantam - that type of tail is often seen in bantams, but I rarely see it in large fowl.
I can't compare the two birds, given the pictures provided.
What will be the defining moment(s) with her and her flock mate is what she produces.