American Idol

[Robin'sBrood]

My take on last night's performances...

Paul was terrible. His singing is starting to grate my nerves and is overshadowing his cuteness and great smile.

Stefano was ok, but I don't like his way of singing and would never vote for him.

Ditto for Jacob.

Haley was bad and didn't get any votes from me. (Dress was WAY too short!)

Scotty was good. He has a great voice, even though I hate still hate country music. I gave him a vote because my 9 year old DD has a crush on him, lol.

Lauren was good and made a cheesy song into one I could actually stand to hear. (It was funny, and true, about Lauren being a much better singer than Miley.) She got a vote from me.

Casey was GREAT with that song, I LOVED it! He got several votes from me.

James should have picked a better song. The one he sang was boring. But, he is still THE BEST on the show this year so he got the most votes from me.

 

[texasgal]

Paul .. I quickly tire of him.

Stefano .. sorry, but I like him .. I do think he or paul will go next.

Jacob .. I quikly tire of him.

Haley .. I like her .. i liked that song .. she is sexy and i don't care who you are .. lol

Scotty .. he just needs to go on and start his country music career

Lauren .. good, but forgettable - as laura said

Casey .. still one of my top two .. the song was FABULOUS .. and when he cuts his first CD, I will own it, and it shall live next to my NORA JONES CDs.. lol

James .. ROCKIN' THE HOUSE WITH JAMES DURBIN .. THAT BOY GETS MY BLOOD FLOWIN' ...

 

[Domestic_goddess]

Paul>He's different and quirky and I like him alot! He's got the Rob Stewart vibe

Stefano>I don't care for him, and I don't feel like I need appologize for that. IMO too common, not different enough

Jacob>I give him props, he's great sing, just getting boring really fast!

Haley>I like her too, she's very talented and different!

Scotty>Doesn't matter what happens with American Idol, he'll go on to great things.

Lauren>She needs few more years of experience.

Casey>LOVE CASEY, he's so different and fun! I would totally buy his cd.

James>I know alot of people like him, but I'm tired of the screaming....He's an Adam Lambert wanna be! Boring and the last 2-3 have been rockers that have won, lets have some different!!!

 

[halo]

I am so glad he's out, he can't sing at all. His looks got him this far.

 

[coloradochick]

So Paul is out? It's just 7pm here now

 

[texasgal]

Well, I called that one .. Paul, Haley, Stefano bottom three ...

I hope after that song Haley and Casey sang .. they see Haley for what she is.. She needs to quit listening to Jimmy Iovine .. and go with her heart!

I love KC and JA duet last nite ..

 

[Mahonri]

Can you believe I have not watched ONE episode this year... but folks are telling me this group is the very most talented.

Perhaps when the Easter Hatch is done.

 

[texasgal]

Quote:
Just in time for the final 6! lol.

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Quote:
I've watched every season except the 1st and this is by far the most talented group I've ever seen! They're all good, some are just better than the rest (James!

)

 

[Winggedheart]

I swear I heard Casey tell Haley he loved her, lol.