American Idol

That rendition of "So What" was HORRENDOUS!!!

I don't watch the show, but THAT was MURDER. Was that Porter Wagner singing with the girls?
Blech! I don't even know what to say.
Lisa​
 
Last edited:
Quote:
I thought Porter Wagner was dead?
lol.png
 
Okay, here's my opinion on tonight's performances..

Casey: Better than usual I thought. I actually liked him and thought he was cute. I don't normally care for him that much, but tonight he has a certain nice enthusiasm about him. He certainly does his own thing (despite the growling, which still annoys me)

Haley: I really liked that song and how she sang it. I was surprised the judges were so-so on it. I thought she did great.

Jacob: aaah, Jacob. I think his own plan bit him in the butt. I saw the rehearsal footage and when he cried singing, it seemed very genuine and I felt for him. BUT: I think he saw the reaction and played up on it during his performance tonight. I think he forced the emotion for effect and it threw him off track. Then he blamed the track being "off"? Come on. I find him to be arrogant pretending to be humble, and that really annoys me.

Lauren: Crap. I forgot what she sang... AGAIN. Enough said. She's cute and sweet, but I ALWAYS forget what the heck she even sang.

Scotty: good a usual, he surely has a career regardless. Tonight was only okay.

Stefano: I really liked his performance tonight actually. At first his attempt at confidence was a little too obvious, but as he went on he seemed to really feel it and put on a good performance. I normally find him lame, but he did good tonight! I also think he's been working out, although I can't help the urge to pat him on the head, trying so hard to be a "lady killer" and all.

James: What else can I say that I haven't said a million times. He never disappoints me. Awesome job tonight as usual, he's still my favorite. He chooses his songs well and often makes them better than the original. Gotta love James.
 
OMG - I couldn't even watch that performance with Paul and the girls - I muted the TV and went and put away dinner dishes. What little I heard was absolutely horrendous. And I was a big Paul fan before that !!

Last night was really good for the most part.

Casey - I loved it !!! I thought it was just awesome. I like him because he is so versatile....he can sing so many types of music in so many different ways. I really did like his little thing with Jennifer at the end - I thought it was sweet (and I think he really does have a MAJOR crush on Jennifer...LOL).

Haley - I thought her song choice was great - I think she was great last night. That is definitely the type of song she needs to sing.

James - I loved it !! James doesn't do much of anything wrong. I also really like James as a person.

Jacob - Ugh. Again, everything he sings sounds the same. I agree with LauraJean's assessment of him. And what was up with that horrible shiny suit?

Stefano - I thought he did a really good job last night - and he is just such a cute little thing.

Scotty - I despised it !! I thought it was awful. I'm not a country music fan at all, but I've always loved Scotty - not so tonight. Pretty lame.

Lauren - I agree with LauraJean there too. She is a beautiful young lady, but she needs to really pick it up. I also normally do not care for her song choices. I don't think they do a thing for her.
 
Awesome show!! I do agree about the first performance though, there is a reason they are no longer in the competition. Stephano is my least favorite and Lauren needs to loosen up, I think she can do so much more. Casey did a wonderful job with that song. I am a fan of Maroon 5 and I was impressed. James, well he has left me speechless once again. I am in awe watching him perform. He is so in his zone when he is up there, a completely different person and most certainly in his element. The kid is a natural rock star. Ok so I wasn't speechless
wink.png
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom