American Idol

[thechickenchick]

Quote:



You are absolutely 100% correct!

 

[Robin'sBrood]

I really, really dislike country music so I'm not enjoying AI right now.

Maybe Haley will do something that isn't country... and will do it well.


ETA... She's doing Led Zeppelin?!

My absolute favorite (secular) band of all time... verdict is still out for me but I sure as heck like it better than Mary J. Blige's version of Stairway to Heaven.

 

[teach1rusl]

I'm a Scotty fan all the way, but I did enjoy Haley's song (although I didn't know it).

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
*CRINGE* okay, starting to feel really old.

I actually did not like it. It sounded good in the rehearsal but sounded really dragged out live and she just was kinda screaming it out at once point. I'm sick of her.

Scotty just doesn't do it for me. Nice guy and all that, just doesn't move me in the least and I'm honestly getting sick of his "humble smile" at the end of every song.

Lauren doesn't thrill me either, but at least she's sweet, I don't know.

Truth is, I just don't care now that James is gone.

 

[Laurajean]

No. no, no, no, no NO. I don't care what anyone says, she should not have TOUCHED Stevie Nicks. I'm especially annoyed at the windblown hair, totally copying Stevie's performances, Stevie was notorious for that. I didn't want a bad Steve Nicks impression, I did not need that. Yes, fine, I'm irritable because James is gone, but that just really aggravated me, bad.

 

[ScissorChick]

Quote:
*CRINGE* okay, starting to feel really old.

I actually did not like it. It sounded good in the rehearsal but sounded really dragged out live and she just was kinda screaming it out at once point. I'm sick of her.

Scotty just doesn't do it for me. Nice guy and all that, just doesn't move me in the least and I'm honestly getting sick of his "humble smile" at the end of every song.

Lauren doesn't thrill me either, but at least she's sweet, I don't know.

Truth is, I just don't care now that James is gone.

I feel they voted all the best people off this year. I to am crushed that James is

gone, he IS amazing, and my favorite.

But ... I am a country fan, I love Lauren, Scotty and Haley. Just my style of music..

Scotty didn't sound good tonight, from what *I* heard, but Lauren killed it, and I

thought Haley did great on her second song.

 

[sgtmom52]

Quote:
She didn't have a choice in that song ~ the 2nd song was picked for them. She did have a choice in how she preformed it though. I thought she did a good job with it.

I really don't like all of the "music videos" that they are showing the past few weeks.

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
She didn't have a choice in that song ~ the 2nd song was picked for them. She did have a choice in how she preformed it though. I thought she did a good job with it.

I really don't like all of the "music videos" that they are showing the past few weeks.

I don't care whose choice it was, it should not have been done. It was like a bad impersonation. I'm sure she didn't choose the windblown hair either, but I still hated it.

 

[teach1rusl]

Quote:
*CRINGE* okay, starting to feel really old.
I actually did not like it. It sounded good in the rehearsal but sounded really dragged out live and she just was kinda screaming it out at once point. I'm sick of her.

Oh, I was born in the mid 60s, so I'm old enough...lol. But I was never a big music person. What I did listen to was country and the old Casey Kasem top 40 type music. But it helps me when I DON'T know the songs, because then I'm not comparing to the original artist. Had I known the song, I might have had a different impression

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
*CRINGE* okay, starting to feel really old.
I actually did not like it. It sounded good in the rehearsal but sounded really dragged out live and she just was kinda screaming it out at once point. I'm sick of her.

Oh, I was born in the mid 60s, so I'm old enough...lol. But I was never a big music person. What I did listen to was country and the old Casey Kasem top 40 type music. But it helps me when I DON'T know the songs, because then I'm not comparing to the original artist. Had I known the song, I might have had a different impression

Born in the 60's and don't know that Zeppelin song???? That's crazy!