American Idol

[Robin'sBrood]

Quote:
*CRINGE* okay, starting to feel really old.

I actually did not like it. It sounded good in the rehearsal but sounded really dragged out live and she just was kinda screaming it out at once point. I'm sick of her.

Scotty just doesn't do it for me. Nice guy and all that, just doesn't move me in the least and I'm honestly getting sick of his "humble smile" at the end of every song.

Lauren doesn't thrill me either, but at least she's sweet, I don't know.

Truth is, I just don't care now that James is gone.

Agreed. I'm not voting tonight because I really don't care which of them wins.

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Quote:
It was terrible and so was her last song!

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Quote:
Oh, I was born in the mid 60s, so I'm old enough...lol. But I was never a big music person. What I did listen to was country and the old Casey Kasem top 40 type music. But it helps me when I DON'T know the songs, because then I'm not comparing to the original artist. Had I known the song, I might have had a different impression

Born in the 60's and don't know that Zeppelin song???? That's crazy!

I was born in the 60's too. Scotty's version of the Kenny Roger's song was horrible, IMO. I remember the KR version from my youth and I always loved it because Kenny put so much feeling into it. Scotty is too young to sing about a woman like that... there was NO feeling in it, because he has never felt that way about a woman before. I wish whomever picked the songs out for them would think about stuff like that.

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

Robin'sBrood :

Quote:
It was terrible and so was her last song!

Didn't like her songs either. Time for her to go.​

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

I thought that Scotty did an amazing job singing "are you gonna kiss me or not". He did a great job with that. Lauren rocked all of the songs, imo.

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
It was terrible and so was her last song!

Didn't like her songs either. Time for her to go.

Yep. I'm sick of her. I guess my order of favorites if I had to choose at this point would be Lauren, then Scotty, then Haley. But I'm not voting either now that James is gone.

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

Quote:
Didn't like her songs either. Time for her to go.

Yep. I'm sick of her. I guess my order of favorites if I had to choose at this point would be Lauren, then Scotty, then Haley. But I'm not voting either now that James is gone.

My order of favorites is the same. I really think that Lauren will win & she deserves it. I remember back when I was watching the auditions and I saw her sing, I said "theres your winner". Can't wait for tomorrow show.

 

[gamebirdsonly]

Quote:
Yep. I'm sick of her. I guess my order of favorites if I had to choose at this point would be Lauren, then Scotty, then Haley. But I'm not voting either now that James is gone.

My order of favorites is the same. I really think that Lauren will win & she deserves it. I remember back when I was watching the auditions and I saw her sing, I said "theres your winner". Can't wait for tomorrow show.

Thats exactly what my wife said

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

When Jennifer asked Scotty to shave his hair down like it was in the auditions, I busted out laughing, thats exactly what I was thinking when they were replaying the auditions.

 

[featherbaby]

A country singer with a shaved head?????Something about that just ain't right. I hope he doesn't shave his head, I think he looks lots better with some hair. I voted for Scotty tonight. I like Lauren a lot too, but I had to choose. Haley is a good performer but her raspy voice and some of the screaming is not my cup 'o tea. She just has a 'hard edge' to her songs that I don't care for. I think this has been the best talent pool they've ever had to choose from. Only tough choices from here on.

I think if I hear Randy say "in it to win it" one more time I'll throw up. It's stupid. They're all in it to win it or they wouldn't be up there singing their hearts out. It's over worked and comes off as insincere since he uses it over and over. Think of something better to say, Randy!

I thought Beyonce's music video was weird, hard and angry. I didn't like it at all. That wasn't dancing, it was synchronized jerking.