I had a roo ( he recently died) he was hatched out of eggs from a known breeder. He had a straight comb (huge), but he had two amazing tufts and perfect coloring. I bred him like crazy and culled everything that had a straight comb(fortunately only 1 in 40 chicks this summer). The only roo I have kept out of him has two huge tufts, a tiny ( so far) pea comb, looks to be rumpless (so far ) and is black. The roo was BBR and I had hoped to get a BBR to replace him but while only one of his offspring looked to have a straight comb, either none of the others were colored right or they didn't have tufts. If I keep the roo chick I will keep on eye on his chicks for comb. But so far I am happy with what came out of his pen. I had the highest percentage of tufted out of his pen.
I know the breeder has good even great birds. He hatched out of a blue egg. Oh well.
Araucana's are rare enough and expensive enough that I work with what I have and see where it takes me. None of my birds are perfect, someday maybe.
Lanae