After reading only page 1 with SMOKE coming out my ears, I have to stick up for hatchery birds. Breeders can see nothing good about them, but those of us who get birds for eggs are plenty pleased. They're right... in general hatchery birds are bred more for production, which is what many of us want.
I've had two orders of rainbow layers from McMurray hatchery, and gotten a lot of really nice birds. They look like what I expected, and I've never had an eggbound chicken. I am more than pleased with McMurray hatchery. The only thing I didn't like about them was the buff orps and Rhode Island reds weren't the wonderful birds that everyone who breeds nice quality orps and RIR's say. They picked on everyone else, and weren't the sweet, friendly girls I'd heard about. I kept the buff orps for a couple of years before we had to re-home the entire flock when we moved. I only kept the RIR's for 18 weeks before finding them a new home.
I've had bantam cochins, welsummers and easter eggers from Ideal, and love them all. My cochins are sweet, calm, cute and VERY broody, which is perfect because that's why I got them. Besides the fact that they add a lot of personality to my flock. My welsummers are beautiful, and are laying as dark of an egg as I expected. They just started a couple of weeks ago, at almost 6 months old. The EE's haven't started laying yet, and I'm anxiously waiting for the color they'll add to my egg basket. I got a very nice assortment of colors of feathering in those EE's, much nicer than the color variety I've had from McMurray (though those birds were pretty).
I've got EE's from Privett hatchery, which came from my feed store. They're all basic EE brown, and too young to lay yet, but they are beautiful. The cockerel is beardless, and one of the pullets doesn't have a perfect peacomb. But I can't wait for their eggs either.
I love my hatchery girls, and get very tired of breeders not understanding that people can be perfectly content with them if they don't conform perfectly to show standards. It just about has me convinced not to ask questions about my hatchery chickens in this part of BYC...