Notice that Ann didn't actually cast a vote
against her "3 Buff Orps (one's a roo)." And, Andy hasn't asked about roo's so let's not drift into evaluating the legitimate crowers of species.
My Buff's would cackle but seldom, the EE's were quiet but I've noted how variable in
everything EE's are said to be by folks with more experience.
It could be that the
dynamics of the flock partly determines the noisy and quiet birds: If Hen A doesn't make a sound it may be as a result of Hen B never letting her get a word in edgewise.
I gotta say that the Barred Rocks are the noisiest I've had even tho' I have one that never cackles, never. She talks constantly - in a soft voice
. Her sister, on the other hand
, complains about absolutely everything. She cackles when the
other hens lay an egg
. She complains about getting out and then for the first 10 minutes while she's out on the lawn. It must take her that long to shift from making noise to foraging.
She is a good laying hen, tho'. I just wish to heck she'd shut up
!!
Steve
Let's see, a vote for the Dominique and another for the Marans and Buff's. And, more votes against the EE's and sex-links. Popularity of the breeds could be entering into this poll . . .