The problem with you analogy is that your dog example does not address the 9 year old child that was attacked/threatened by the rooster. You may not kill the dog but would you still keep it when it was threatening to attack and harm your child? I suspect no, that you would get rid of it.
I couldn't agree more. The fact that he has attacked a child just once is enough to get rid if him, if not to the soup pot then at least to someone who has no children around, and is willing to put up with his terrible behaviour towards them. There are no second chances when it comes to attacking a child.
Off with his head is a lot to do. Think of it like This when a dog barks at you like trying to attack do you kill the dog? No (hopefully ) wack him even time he even come near you aggressively. Don't. Run or act scared they will keep doing it knowing they have that effect on you. If you do kill him it would be a fail in a way. you raised the rooster for protection and chicks.
One could argue that 'whacking him' over and over again to teach him a lesson is also an unacceptable outcome. At some point you do have to draw a line in the sand. At the end of the day, aggression towards humans can be an inherited trait. It's not something that you would ever want to breed on in your chicks. Roosters are a dime a dozen, and if you want one for the protection of your flock, you can pick one up for little to no expense. One that not only protects his flock, but doesn't threaten you every time you walk outside your home!
This rooster already knows he has the upper hand. As @angeladare said originally, she ran into the house to escape him - and wisely so! I wouldn't hang around to be attacked either! However, in doing so, that rooster now knows that if he attacks, he will win. And whilst it's not impossible to change a rooster's behaviour, I doubt it is the norm.
I know that the culling of birds is not an ideal ending, but there are some behaviours that truly do warrant it. In my personal opinion, attacking a child is one of them. Ask yourself, would you risk a small child going outside alone with a rooster like that? How many chances do you want to give him to take out an eye or harm them otherwise with their spurs? Once it's done, it's done.
I do appreciate and respect that others may have differing opinions.
- Krista