Thank y'all for your comments. Every picture I took of the birds was when they were on the move so I agree that it is hard to make good calls without hands on. He is young, only 8 months old so I am not worried about him filling out. His legs are well spread even though the pics don't show it. The hen next to him in the 2nd pic is his grandmother and in person she is a winner. He will be bred to her eventually. My main concern is his tail angle and width. On that I totally agree. SOP calls for 40 degree and when I look at the colored pic in the 2010 SOP I see higher than 40 degree so that is where I am confused. His grandfather Dundee had a much better tail and so did most of his fathers and brothers that I ate or sold, so kick me now! I also do not like his comb with the split point. It will be interesting to see what he throws in the future. I really miss his grandfather Dundee, and wonder if I will ever get back to that awesome type. I am starting a second flock of BA's from a different line thanks to Stan at Tigercreek. I will continue with my Duane Urch line using Mick and see how they fair. I have to weigh the pros and cons of both different lines to see if it will be worth crossing a few years down the road. Time and alot of breeding and culling will tell. Some breeders say never cross lines, but I personally know people who have and got good results. So lets lay in on that one and that should keep this thread going.