Trisha- thank you, so much to learn. It is alot of common sense-like you said. 2 steps forward..1 step back..can be applied to a great many things! I must admit I do judge alot by the looks, I guess I have to start somewhere, but would always want to work-towards a "complete" package. Thank you again Trish.One more thing...Sometimes breeding good birds may not be just breeding the best to the best. It may be necessary to breed two birds together that will complement each other or fix "extremes". High tail set...to low. Great lacing, but small, to a big but not so well laced bird. Etc, Etc. Not all show quality birds come from pairing SQ birds. And pairing up SQ birds does not always equal SQ either.
Egg color is also a factor. You may want to keep a hen with shafting and peppering....if she lays a darker egg. If you cull her and only keep the "pretty" ones...you may loose those dark egg genes. Just evaluate each bird's strengths and weaknesses individually. Eventually you'll end up with what you want your birds to be. Sometimes it's 2 steps forward...one step back
Trisha
Danielle