Biology Extra Credit Question... **ANSWER POSTED**

JMajors wrote: Check out this link.....I believe it is humans and it is related to the GENDER not the SEX of the human. Read it, very interesting.

http://www.learner.org/courses/biology/units/gender/experts/vilain.html

OH YEAH, look at "How do you study gender? " section

Exactly (from your link - and an excellent link it is): "Studying gender is complicated: first because there is no animal model for it. You have to study humans."

There is more politics than science involved with this particular term (if you like, search for operational definitions of gender in research). In the life sciences `gender' is most often substituted for `sex', in social sciences the definitions are often just what one likes (making it hard to replicate/falsify).

This is an interesting take on the situation: http://www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/hrj/iss18/charlesworth.shtml

From
the link:

"Perhaps the most fundamental problem with the strategy of gender mainstreaming is that it rests on an insipid and bland concept of gender that has little cutting edge. In some contexts, the U.N. has followed the “second wave” of feminist thought in drawing a clear distinction between the concepts of “sex” and “gender.”[85] It has thus defined sex as a matter of biology and gender as the constructed meaning of sex, and the designation of social roles.[86] This distinction has now come under scrutiny from feminist scholars, who have questioned whether the category of “sex” can be regarded as natural and uncontentious.[87]" (italics mine).

An example of research in which `sex' is replaced by `gender,' and it muddies the issue (download the pdf and replace every instance of `gender' with `sex').

http://jpet.aspetjournals.org/cgi/content/full/286/1/191

So, yes, I `understand' what the teacher meant to say but (as suggested by Patandchickens), The Big Book of Hyena gender? I think not. I'm simply reminded of other words used in science that lacked operative clarity:
Eugenic1919.jpg
 
Last edited:
First off I'm questioning the wording of your teacher's question. Do you have it in writing? I'm asking just to be sure the question you posted is how the instructor wrote it.
 
Last edited:
All I can find is either a giraffe or a hyena....they're the only two with longer front legs, unless Google is hiding something....I read a bit about hyena reproduction, and it doesn't say anything about gender determination, but the giraffe's cycle has something to do with the rainy season...don't know if that translates to gender determination....Now that I'm done searching for the answer for a hour and a half, let us know if you get 3 EC points!!! LOL!!!
 
I would say that the hyena would be about the only one, but it is b/c the females look like males, but like you - nothing states that gender is determined after birth.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hmm Maybe the teacher doesn't have the answer either and that's why she gave everyone an extra day?
tongue.png
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom