Quote:
YHF, I realize that not every comment here can apply to everyone all the time, and would like to take exception to your comments above about breeding to the SOP and not showing.
These are my thoughts and since I'm new to this world(only have hatchery stock at this time because that's all I knew to exist when we wanted to get started), someone please correct me if I'm wrong. And please don't take offense. My wife often tells me that I act like a jacka$$ to people, even though that completely wasn't my intention.
Would your Dorkings retain their meat quality if you didn't breed toward the SOP? Would your Anconas lay like they do if you didn't breed toward the SOP? It's often stated here that if you're not breeding towards a goal, then the quality of your stock is diminishing. We could probably wing it and breed chickens to do what we wanted: Bigger breast meat, bigger eggs, more eggs...whatever we wanted to do, we could do it blind. However, doesn't that come at the detriment of the chicken? If we wanted to raise Dorkings for meat, what would happen to the quality of the meat if we didn't have a goal? Would it retain its fine grain that they're famous for? Or would it deteriorate if we bred them for size or faster grow rates and ignored the head, comb, wings, feathers, shape, tails, etc.?
From what I've gathered here, the SOP is the goal that gives the Dorkings their meat quality and the Anconas their egg production year after year without their bodies failing after 2 years like hatchery chickens. Without that goal, I could get the best of any breed, and turn it into hatchery stock(or worse) in a year or 2.
Even though my wife and I have talked about letting our daughters show if they want to when they're old enough, we currently have no intentions of showing. We ordered our SOP and look through it when we have conversations to try to pick a breed to start with. Which, BTW, is the hardest part of our whole chicken experience to date. From reading Bob, fowlman, Fred, YHF, Kathy, 3rivers, catdaddy, and many more, it has been hammered into me that this is the direction to go, even if I don't want to show.
Please correct my thoughts or argue with me if I'm wrong. A fella that I work with has a saying taped up on his wall. "I never learned anything from anyone that didn't disagree with me." Author Unknown. So argue with me so that I may learn.
Happily(not jacka$$ly), colburg