I have a somewhat gruesome question but it's to ensure the most humane method of killing for eating while getting the best meat quality. I'm doing as much research as I can so the rooster has a stay of execution until I'm sure about all this. In the meantime he has started to crow :-/ so it's almost time.
I've been reading that when you cut the veins and let the chicken bleed out, you get more blood out of the meat than if you chop the head off. I also watched a video where someone cut the throat and then immediately stuck the knife into the brain through the mouth, killing the chicken instantly so they didn't wait to die by bleeding to death. That looked pretty humane for the chicken.
I really have to do a good job with this first chicken, the meat cannot be gamey and in fact the more it tastes like commercial chicken the better, or it will be tough to get my husband to eat any more of our chickens.
Does killing the chicken instantly after cutting its throat ensure less blood in the meat, or is that about the same as just chopping off the head? My guess is that just bleeding gives you the best meat, is there really any difference?
Does brining reduce gamey taste?
Since feeding fermented feed, I don't ever taste any gamey or barnyard flavor in my chickens, so not sure that it has anything to do with brining or bleeding so much as what they have to eat. What I consider as "gamey" is that taste of their feed, but after fermenting it, it doesn't seem to impart that chicken feed flavor any longer.
If you have to brine meat to remove a bad flavor, it's got to be pretty bad meat. I've never had to brine a chicken, nor any meat we've processed here, though we have marinated them in a good BBQ sauce and lemon juice prior to grilling before...that seems to add a wonderful dimension to their tenderness and flavor on the grill. Will be doing that with some cockerels come Wed. night here.
I've tried the pithing and it was gruesome and not even close to being humane...the birds were still alive as brainy gore rolled out of their mouths. I scrambled every brain cell they ever had and it still never killed them...finally had to cut the throat and give them mercy. Never again.
I just cut one side of the throat and let it bleed out, then cut off the head and proceed with the butcher. Leaving the head on seems to add weight to the neck and direct the flow of blood downward, even if they move around a bit....cutting off the head entirely seems to result in a lot more blood spray as the stump of the neck moves about in the death throws and gets more blood on the neck feathers by the time it's done bleeding out. I've tried nearly every method you can use to make a chicken dead over 40 yrs, short of shooting one, and have found the cutting of the neck with a sharp knife to be my favorite for a quick kill and less mess.
There truly is no way to calculate which results in a better bleed out as chickens don't really have that much blood in the first place and it's not likely you'll encounter any in the muscle tissue when it's all said and done. I've killed hundreds and hundreds of birds and never encountered blood seeping from the muscle fibers when cutting them up later on.
I use a 2 gal. bleach jug killing cone tacked to a tree...makes for nice, hands free working. Fits any size bird, even the big ol' overgrown CX.
A sharp knife is your best and most simple tool for the butchering, from start to finish.