I've got a blue orpington and a BR, along with an Ameracuna-- all girls, no rooster. All three are very friendly and let me pet them and pick them up. But I do prefer my BR because: 1) my BO is loud, she is always making a racket for no apparent reason; 2) my BO goes broody often, and with no rooster there is no need for that; and 3) my BR is a much more consistent layer. My BR started laying in late October and so far has missed laying on only 6 days. My BO lays about 5 eggs per week.