So looking at the birds yesterday and considering my porcelain satin project, I need to decide how to proceed for adding mottling into the line. Currently, my choices, as far as females, all have different pros and cons, none of them are "perfect" (but are they ever really though?)
So, maybe someone can step in and help me make some decisions.
My Lavender Isabella cockerels are full silkies but none of them have great type. One of them has a much bigger crest and cushion, and I'm keeping my eye on him. I would prefer to start with a full lavender bird not a split so I have everyone split to lavender on my first cross instead of a small percentage of them. I planned to cross a lavender Cockerel with either a regular Mille Fleur hen or just a mottled hen. And then would breed those I selected from the first generation back to the father. Also, thinking I will run a parallel pen with the split roo at the same time. The choices for hens right now are as follows:
#1- I have one full mille fleur pullet that is a D'uccle (possibly a mix with Serama not entirely sure- hatched on another farm) She has Muffs and beard, light foot feathering, and is MF patterned. Bantam size will be correct. Cons- type is COMPLETELY different then what you would go for in a silkie. They are much more upright built. Her pattern, I think, will end up having too much white. Due to the amount of mottling she already shows pre molt. Also, I will have to battle straight and modified combs but that will be true no matter what I choose
#2- Black and white mottled Cochin (2 full mottled and I think I have one or two black split to mottling) - body type is closer to what I would look for in a silkie, much more low to the ground and horizontal build then the D'uccle. She also has a cushion instead of a full tail. Bantam size will stay right. Will still be battling straight combs, but she is also clean faced so I will have birds that don't express Muffs and beards too. There is also some debate in the project group over whether I will actually get decent pattern porcelain birds by using a mottled bird versus a MF patterned bird. Sidenote- these two particular hens also have a chance of being split to silkie feathering. They came from a line with silkie feathering and several of their siblings are actually fully expressed silkied cochins.
#3- Last choice, and also longest to fulfill, would be to wait and use the lavender mottled bantam cochins chicks I'm currently brooding as 2-3 wk olds. Cons would be that almost all of them appear to be males, only two of the seven look pullet to me, but that could be wrong. I will be waiting 8-12 months before I can even think about Hatching from them. I don't like Hatching pullet eggs. They're Bantam, so size would stay correct. Plus side is almost all are frizzle so I will be able to breed in the frizzle gene with them. Which I intend to do later anyways. They will definitely be used to darken the lavender gene later as well. They are all mottled or split to mottling. Using them for a future generation will take me back again with traits but I think the benefits (better mottling, better lavender, and frizzle) will all be worth it. These chicks are also much better type then the hens I currently have.
#4- And just a wild after thought really is that I also have a mottled Houdan. But it is male so it would have to be used second generation if I produce more lavender silkies first. Houdans have a V comb (not sure if it's dominant or not) they also have 5 toes and Muffs and beards. White skin. Totally different body type but are known for being great layers so that would definitely be nice.
#5- I have a handful (3) of way better type bantam cochins but none of them are MF or mottled. They are partridge. I think. From a different line then my others but they also could be spilt to mottling and split to silkied feathers. I also have 3-4 cockerels from this same hatch and two of my those are full pattern MF. They are boys though so I don't know how it helps at all
