At the very least, if this is a common practice, hatcheries should clarify this. It's a terrible position for many folks to be in to dispense of or dispatch a rooster when there was never supposed to be one. If I had not known I'd receive a rooster, I'd certainly take the extra chick. Thankfully I was aware of Meyer's policy and have always received accurately sexed chicks. I was simply saying I didn't agree with the policy of throwing in a free unexpected male. Personally, I can handle keeping or eating the extra male, but I've been on the other side of the fence too.