Quote:
I've got both (adult) but no keats or ducklings right now...
so as for which to order...
- guineas are loud
- duck hens are loud, but not as frequently as guineas
- duck drakes are not loud, but you have to either have all drakes, or a balanced ratio of hens to drakes (3-8 hens per drake)
- duck poop is messy and they poop wherever they go
- guinea poop is messy, but mostly I see it where they roost, not as much all over (but it still depends on where they go)
- if you have them in a pen, neither is a problem
- ducks use a lot more water, but if you have a pool or pond, they'll make their mess there (we don't put water in with them at night so their night pen is dryer). if their pool or pond is in their pen, it will be wet and messy
- ducks have to have enough water to get their heads submerged (for nostril cleaning) but will love you for giving them a pond
- guineas don't need a pond, but will drink out if one.
- guineas will roost in your trees or other inconvenient areas if left to their own choice, but you can teach them where to roost.
- ducks want to be up all night, but will learn to go in their night pen if you teach them to.
- we've lost both to coyotes, but only lost guineas to the hawks (mostly the light-colored ones)
- some duck breeds are exceptional layers
- guineas are much better at hiding their nests than ducks
- some duck breeds lay nearly year round
- guineas are seasonal layers
- duck and guinea eggs are all tasty
- ducks will eat bugs and slugs and snails
- guineas will eat bugs and ticks
- ducks will make a mudpie out of any area that's got standing water. and enlarge it with enthusiasm
- ducks are goofy
- guineas are nuts
- and goofy.
there... does that help you decide?