Hi All ,
I just skimmed through this thread and will read through all of it later.i have been breeding and showing ACD's here in Fl for 9 years now. I have only had 2 litters because I believe in breeding responsibly. I do all the DNA and health testing recommended.
My dogs are MODERATE and come from good lines where many of the dogs have herding titles, I live too far from stock to compete in but always have my dogs instinct tested. I agree that SOME people are breeding for overly heavy dogs with piggy heads, these dogs can't move for the life of them. Fortunately a lot of the judges look at movement as a huge part of our breed. My girl Emmie ( my avatar ) who is expecting a litter May23rd. is a bit leggy and doesn't have a huge head but finished her championship very easily with 4 majors beating the winners dog for 2 of those wins. So there is hope , I will always choose a dog that is a little longer that can move rather than a overdone dog with a huge head!
There is no reason why you can't have a nice looking, healthy dog that can do the job it was bred to do. I find the people in Fl who advertise "Heelers " are usually backyard breeders who do no health testing at all. I have seen blind dogs, deaf dogs and dogs with hip dysplasia come from these places. They are also usually huge. I have 2 heelers that come to me for grooming , both are females and weigh over 65lbs. One is severely displastic and he dieted her down from 75 lbs. They are too big and even if healthy would be unable to be quick enough to work stock.
Oh and by the way I do believe Skidboot went blind of PRA ( I saw a video of him in his old age and you could tell he couldn't see well ) but not before he went ahead and bred him ! Yes he was an amazing dog but there is no excuse for breeding dogs with PRA witht the testing we have now! I now see they are breeding puppies like crazy but see no info at all that any are tested for PRA, hip, elbow problems or deafness. I may be wrong but good breeders post all of this info on their sites ........
Missie