I have used both LG and GQF hovabator model 2362N with pitiful hatch results. My old Brower pancake style incubator from the 70's era however is very consistant and I have no complaints. Hope this helps.
I just ordered the Genesis 1588 from Home and Barn Basics. With the auto turner and shipping, plus BYC discount, my total was $157.97. That is the cheapest price that I was able to find.
If you decide to order from them, the promo code is BYC5. That gives you a 5% discount.
Mine is supposed to ship today. I can't wait. I hope I made the right decision....