Cockerel Selection

thlayli

Songster
7 Years
Jan 18, 2017
209
275
181
Norwalk, IA
I hatched out a batch of eggs about 6 weeks ago and it looks like 6 of the 11 are cockerels (comb and wattle growth + red shoulders are my primary indicators). They're a little young to determine which are definitely keepers but I'm hoping some of the more experienced chicken tenders can give me some insight.

My flock is:
9 pullets: 4 older 12 week old pullets, 5 from the batch I mentioned
7 cocks: 1 Orpington boy 12 weeks old, and the other 6 are the ones in question.


The chicks are Icelandics, which means they don't have a breed standard to conform to since they're a landrace. All of the boys look different - some are brown, some are blue, I've got one that is a mottled mix of about five different colors, and there's a variety of crests as well, to speak nothing of the combs. Temperment-wise, they're pretty respectful. They've done some chest bumping, and a couple have even stood up to my older orpington cockerel. The older pullets that used to bully them will now make way for a few of the Icie boys. I do have one or two that will come and sit on my lap when I hang out in the coop with them.

My question is, is there any indication that any of this behavior will "turn bad" once they hit puberty? Are the friendlier ones that don't mind sitting on me destined to be wuss bunnies? Do I need to worry that, at 6 weeks, the ones already starting to spar will become more aggressive? Is it just plain too early to tell? Feed is expensive, Icelandics aren't that common, and I just don't have the room to wait for half my flock to flip the switch on their testosterone and then turn into little tyrants, so I'm trying to pick out the ones that need to go and, well, get them gone. My problem is that there isn't anything really egregious or alarming about their behavior to help me pick the winners from the losers.
 
The boys in question. If it makes a difference
 

Attachments

  • 20230108_141555.jpg
    20230108_141555.jpg
    834.2 KB · Views: 8
  • 20230108_141855.jpg
    20230108_141855.jpg
    459.9 KB · Views: 7
  • 20230108_142013.jpg
    20230108_142013.jpg
    407.8 KB · Views: 9
  • 20230108_142118.jpg
    20230108_142118.jpg
    674.7 KB · Views: 7
  • 20230108_142146.jpg
    20230108_142146.jpg
    709.4 KB · Views: 7
  • 20230108_142246.jpg
    20230108_142246.jpg
    841.3 KB · Views: 7
This is my two cents - an a lot depends on your own set up.

I am assuming that you want to keep an Iceland rooster? I am hoping that you have an alternative coop/run.

I would not pick the birds sitting on your lap. To inexperienced people this often seems quite friendly, but truthfully IMO, the human is taking the submissive position, and these friendly cockerels often times become more and more aggressive. In chickens a little fear = respect, and they don't have it.

There is a very good chance, that the cockerels will become way too much for your pullets, if that happens put all of them in the bachelor pad just to give your pullets time to start laying.

Around 16 weeks, give or take, cull 3-4 that you don't like for any reason, even if the reason is, I think I like these 3-4 better. This will change the dynamics of the remaining birds, how is anyone's guess. Then as they get closer to 20 months, and your pullets start to lay. Pick one that you like, put him in with the girls, and see how it goes.

If they are not in love by morning - or at the very most, a couple of days, try a different cockerel. Cull down to 2 possible contenders.

Wait another month - and by then -6 months of age, I am betting one will be standing out.

Mrs K
 
BIG OOF. I haven't been getting ANY notifications on this thread yall. I apologize for the radio silence!

First, thank you for your replies. I really appreciate any insight yall can offer. The last time I had a bunch of cockerels (8 out of 10 eggs were boys...) I just donated them to a raptor rehabilitation center when I was certain they were boys.

And, yes, I am certain that all the animals in the pictures I took are cocks. C: It's a little harder to see on the brown bird, but he has a very vivid comb. You can't even see the combs or wattles on the pullets yet.

I don't have another coop to set up a bachelor flock, otherwise I'd probably just keep all of them lol. I don't want to make my 9 pullets go through 8 cockerels all hitting puberty at about the same time, which is why I want to get them out as early as I can. Ideally I keep 2 Icie boys, but if push comes to shove one will be fine. I was just hoping there was some proto-problematic behavior I could zero in on to help the selection process, but if they're too young then I guess I just go with 'I like you and not you'.
 
Here's a better photo of the brown boy, and then a comparative photo of a pullet with 2 cockerels in the bg. They all got their combs and wattles at, like, 5 weeks, which was pretty surprising to me.
 

Attachments

  • 20230111_124622.jpg
    20230111_124622.jpg
    407.1 KB · Views: 3
  • 20230111_124818.jpg
    20230111_124818.jpg
    863.1 KB · Views: 4

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom