Compare Nutrena vs. Purina

i personally think nutrena makes them smell really bad. so i use puriena

What do you mean, "makes them smell bad..." Like, the birds themselves or makes their poop smell more? My girls are currently on Purina chick starter but are just about ready to move over to Layer feed and I'm looking at my options.
 
What do you mean, "makes them smell bad..." Like, the birds themselves or makes their poop smell more? My girls are currently on Purina chick starter but are just about ready to move over to Layer feed and I'm looking at my options.

Hi,
I am in the USA. I had UK strains of Light Sussex. I liked the Agway Meatbird and the Nutrena Meatbird. Both by Cargill. Everyone in my Sussex flock of all ages ate it and did real well.
Best,
Karen
 
I don't buy Nutrena because it's owned by Cargill, a supporter of NAIS. I don't recall if it has animal protein in it, which, in my way of thinking, would be good. Also, I used to live down the road from one of the Cargill plants. Yuck, sometimes the air in the n'hood smelled like I was suffocating in a bag of dogfood.
What is the NAIS and what’s the deal with it?
 
What is the NAIS and what’s the deal with it?
National Animal Identification System.

Some years ago, it was an idea of the United States Government for identifying and keeping track of all livestock-type animals. They hoped to be able to track animal diseases, by tracking which animals were where and had been in contact with which other animals.

The plan was to make it mandatory for the entire country. That would have meant every chicken and every other livestock animal getting an id chip, every owner registering their property information with the government, and every owner filling out forms every time an animal was bought, sold, butchered, or taken off the property for any reason.

There were some exceptions to make it easier for large groups, such as filling out a single form when transporting or butchering an entire herd of cattle or flock of chickens, instead of a separate form for each individual animal in that herd or flock.

Many chicken keepers opposed it, and so did many other people who had just a few animals. I don't know what the big commercial farmers thought about it.

I haven't heard much about it in quite a few years. I know it did not become mandatory. I'm not sure whether it still exists as a voluntary program, or whether it was abandoned entirely.

If you want more information, this wikipedia article looks fairly good at present:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Animal_Identification_System
 
National Animal Identification System.

Some years ago, it was an idea of the United States Government for identifying and keeping track of all livestock-type animals. They hoped to be able to track animal diseases, by tracking which animals were where and had been in contact with which other animals.

The plan was to make it mandatory for the entire country. That would have meant every chicken and every other livestock animal getting an id chip, every owner registering their property information with the government, and every owner filling out forms every time an animal was bought, sold, butchered, or taken off the property for any reason.

There were some exceptions to make it easier for large groups, such as filling out a single form when transporting or butchering an entire herd of cattle or flock of chickens, instead of a separate form for each individual animal in that herd or flock.

Many chicken keepers opposed it, and so did many other people who had just a few animals. I don't know what the big commercial farmers thought about it.

I haven't heard much about it in quite a few years. I know it did not become mandatory. I'm not sure whether it still exists as a voluntary program, or whether it was abandoned entirely.

If you want more information, this wikipedia article looks fairly good at present:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Animal_Identification_System
Thank you. Yeah I’d be against having to do that as well.
 
Well both are made by Cargill. I would suspect that they come off of the same line. The Nutrena brand used to be a European brand and was bought by Cargill. Purina the most recognized brand in agriculture was also bought by Cargill. They charge a bit more for Purina where I live so maybe the ingredients are a bit more expensive. I keep detailed records and if you are free feeding chickens tend to eat just a bit more Nutrena and lay the same number of eggs with both. That also makes me think there are a bit more fillers in Nutrena and the chickens compensate by eating a bit more. Or maybe it was just the weather.
I thought it was Land O Lakes that owns Purina
 
Your comment is true for Europe but not for the United States. Nutrena is a brand owned by Cargill while Purina is a brand owned by Land O'Lakes Cooperative.
My Understanding is Purina is owned by the Swiss multinational Nestle. Personally I trust that brand not nearly as far as I can throw a 50lb bag of their feed.
 
My Understanding is Purina is owned by the Swiss multinational Nestle. Personally I trust that brand not nearly as far as I can throw a 50lb bag of their feed.
Your understanding is more than a little inaccurate, and congratulations on resurrecting a thread opened in 2009 and last commented on, correctly, a year ago.

This isn't a secret. And has been repeated ad infinitum for many many years. Here are posts from 2014, 2017, another from 2019. I can find LOTS or more recent posts from when conspiracy theories started making the rounds (again) in 2022 and '23. Which is the usual source for errors such as your own. and of course you can simply check the corporate web sites, which are linked to in many of the posts. I can find even older posts, if required - the wonder is that anyone still believes this, or continues to trust their original source for this claim (and the usually associated conspiracies) when it is so trivially disproven.

Nestle Purina has a subsidiary (Purina PetCare) producing dog & cat food.

Purina Animal Nutrition (making chicken and other livestock feeds) is a subsidiary of Land O Lakes.

Cargill licenses use of the Purina Brand Logo (the Checkerboard) in the EU.


[Yes, this response might appear a little harsh - but when a bunch of new posters show up, no prior posts, and start making the same claims on multiple threads, I begin to suspect their purpose in doing so is not education, nor honest error]
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom