- Thread starter
- #11
I have no argument with retlaw's advocacy for the use of natural substances - we garden organically and avoid using synthetic chemicals, whenever possible. And I would always choose natural compounds over synthetic ones, whenever there is a choice. For that matter, arsenic is a natural compound that can do some good, by killing blackhead larvae in turkeys, as well as doing some very bad things, like killing ducks and geese. And I understand that black walnut, wormwood and cayenne all have some applications to controlling parasitic worms in animals. So if it is possible that one of them, or some combination, could control blackhead or the cecal worm as well? If so, bring it on!
But I don't see this as an issue of "natural" vs "synthetic" chemicals. To use either one, you need to have solid knowledge about the effectiveness of an application - when the well-being of your feathered family is at stake. Obtaining that knowledge doesn't require a Big Pharma sponsor, it just requires a substance to test and a sound research design to evaluate the effectiveness of that substance. Maybe there are such studies out there on cayenne, or some other natural, (or even synthetic) substances that have been shown to be effective at preventing blackhead in mixed flocks. If so, it would be great to know about them! I would love to have access to a safe, effective blackhead prevention agent - so I could get my chickens and turkeys back together again.
But I don't see this as an issue of "natural" vs "synthetic" chemicals. To use either one, you need to have solid knowledge about the effectiveness of an application - when the well-being of your feathered family is at stake. Obtaining that knowledge doesn't require a Big Pharma sponsor, it just requires a substance to test and a sound research design to evaluate the effectiveness of that substance. Maybe there are such studies out there on cayenne, or some other natural, (or even synthetic) substances that have been shown to be effective at preventing blackhead in mixed flocks. If so, it would be great to know about them! I would love to have access to a safe, effective blackhead prevention agent - so I could get my chickens and turkeys back together again.