I am so glad you found a good church group that could help you.We left because we were searching for truth. We had exhausted our options in the Amish setting. We had gone to everyone (counselors, spiritual guides etc...) that we thought should have answers to our questions which were spiritual in nature because of what we were reading in the bible. Non could give us satisfactory biblical answers to satisfy the longing within to be guilt free. I carried a burden around that I had no idea how to get rid of and no one in the Amish setting ever told us to: Repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand. There really wasn't a real repenting of sin, it was simply "get baptized" and that will take care of all your problems. I got baptized at 22 and it simply added to my problems because everything that I was told would happen "if you only get baptized" didn't happen, none of it. My conscience was not cleansed by baptism.
Three years later I got married. That pretty quickly went downhill hard. It was the bad marriage that made me desperate to find answers to my problems. Divorce was not an option, I was convinced that it was up to me to find a solution and if that meant leaving the Amish setting, I was willing to do it. It was very difficult to leave.
It wasn't until we left the Amish setting and we were in a church group that we were comfortable with, that someone preached a message on, The Worth Of A Soul. The way he described what Jesus went through to rescue me from my sin, just pierced the hard shell that I had erected around myself. I finally began in a small way to understand the absolute LOVE that Jesus had for me. It was that absolute PURE LOVE that found it's way into my heart and conscience, that convicted me to repent (turn away from) the wrong things in my life and there was plenty to repent of. I knew that there had been a change within initially, but I didn't really get the full realization of it until 2 months afterward. At the time I worked for an outdoor furniture manufacturer and happened to be alone at the shop, as we called it. For some reason I don't understand, as I was working and reflecting on my life, I suddenly realized that, I'm not guilty anymore! It was a very refreshing freeing moment! I was able to back track in my mind to the exact time that I was set free from my sin. To this day I remember it as though it happened yesterday.
This is the short version.